Autism Therapy: effectiveness

definition of effectiveness: not yet defined.

No Factsheets to Display

Behavior Modification, by Ma, H. - H., published in 2009, summarized Oct 21, 2010

Some applied behavior analysis (ABA) approaches are more helpful than others when teaching social skills to people with autism.

The aim of this review article was to compare applied behavior analysis (ABA) techniques to treat autism. The study found five helpful ways to use ABA: priming, self-control, training, positive reinforcement plus punishment, and presenting preferential activities. These interventions were helpful for all ages and both genders. The least helpful use of ABA was in teaching perspective-taking skills. The author found that it worked better to train social skills as a whole instead of training just a single type of social skill.


J Autism Dev Disord, by Gibson, JA, Grey IM, and Hastings RP, published in 2009, summarized Aug 19, 2010

Regular and high quality supervision of applied behavior analysis (ABA) therapists may improve the success of ABA intervention.

The focus of this study was on how ABA therapists feel about their work. The survey, of 81 therapists working in ABA schools, found that the therapists who were the most happy had the most support from their bosses. The therapists who received the most support from their bosses also felt that they were doing the best job with the students. The best bosses were those who showed empathy for the therapists and who had a style that rewarded the good choices of the therapists. The study was performed in Ireland, but the authors note that it did not include all ABA therapists in Ireland.


Am J Clin Nutr, by James, SJ, Melnyk S., Fuchs G., Reid T., Jernigan S., Pavliv O., Hubanks A., and Gaylor DW, published in 2009, summarized Aug 17, 2010

Vitamin B12 and folic acid may help to normalize the metabolism of children with autism.

Around 74% of parents use complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) to treat their children with autism. The goal of this study was to show whether or not vitamin B12 and folic acid could improve markers in the blood of children with autism. The authors measured SAM:SAH and GSH:GSSG in the blood of 40 children aged 2 to 7 years who had autism. The children were given 75 µg/kg of vitamin B12 (methylcobalamin) 2 times/week and 400 µg folinic acid 2 times/day for 3 months. The vitamins improved the blood results in the children, but did not bring the blood results to normal levels.


BMC Clinical Pharmacology, by Adams, JB, Baral M., Geis E., Mitchell J., Ingram J., Hensley A., Zappia I., and Newmark S., published in 2009, summarized Apr 27, 2010

A single round of DMSA chelation therapy may improve the severity of autism.

The purpose of this study was to see if DMSA therapy is safe and helpful for children with autism. The authors used five tools to assess changes in autism symptoms. Three of the tools (PDD-BI, SAS and PGI) showed improved behaviors in the children who were given one round of DMSA therapy, and those who were given seven rounds of DMSA therapy. The authors believe that one round of treatment may be enough for some children to excrete toxic metals. The children who released the most metals (thallium, arsenic, mercury, and lead) were the ones with the most improved autism symptoms.


A Michigan school district has joined forces with several organizations to provide post-high school resources for kids with autism and other developmental needs. The Berkley School District, the Judson Center of Royal Oak, and Michigan Rehabilitation Services hope to help young adults transition into life beyond education. Services provided include school instruction at the nearby community college, independent living skills training, and work experience at Providence Hospital. Judson Center has provided a group home where people can learn cooking skills, laundry skills, and other skills needed for independent living. The transition specialist at the home uses dialectic behavior therapy (DBT). DBT is comprised of four components: core mindfulness; distress tolerance, emotion regulation, and interpersonal effectiveness.

Read original article: Berkley Gives Special Education Students a Postsecondary Boost


Tui na, a form of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), may help children with autism improve sensory issues and self-regulatory deficits. A recent research study, A Model and Treatment for Autism at the Convergence of Chinese Medicine and Western Science: First 130 Cases, looked at 130 children with autism who received Tui na, Their parents were taught how to administer the technique, which is a hands-on approach that includes brushing, kneading, and pressing on areas of the body. Not only did the children show increased improvements in sensory issues, but parents showed less stress as well.

Read original article: Autism Treatment Research Focuses on Efficacy of Chinese Medicine Tuina Methodology


Floortime is gaining in popularity even as some experts deny hard evidence that proves its effectiveness. This form of play therapy for children with autism was developed by Stanley Greenspan. "Rather than focusing on developing specific skills, it's geared toward helping children establish relationships."

Read original article.



Please comment on this autism topic.

Unique Oppertunity NDAR Study

New research for alternative therapies for ASD children and their families. Allowing us to observe your family and your child in an setting that is safe and ASD friendly FREE to families in need and be a part of a National study that gathers research data on non-traditional therapies. We are offering a chance in a lifetime. Dr Annabel Agee PhD,  and Equine Specialist, Lisenced reflexologist, and 20 yr counselor and alternative health, and child advocate will be accepting applications for ASD families to be a part of our National Study to provide data for NDAR. National Data for Autistic Reasearch. For coming to us and allowing us to document progress as we utilize exposure to a very calm very grounding expreience and interaction with trained equine therapy horses, you will be a part of an elite study which will hopefully be extremely valuable data for research on the effectiveness of alternative therapies for ASD children. What makes us really unique is that we aslo will be working with the entire family as a unit not just the child. 

We are Horses Help Hearts Heal 

Dr Annabel Agee Phd, LPC, NCC, MHSP, 
 
Melissa Blaque, RCR, LRT, EALS, ES, DVLA, CASA
for more information please call: 865-206-7947 or 865-208-9555


Unique Oppertunity NDAR Study

New research for alternative therapies for ASD children and their families. Allowing us to observe your family and your child in an setting that is safe and ASD friendly FREE to families in need and be a part of a National study that gathers research data on non-traditional therapies. We are offering a chance in a lifetime. Dr Annabel Agee PhD,  and Equine Specialist, Lisenced reflexologist, and 20 yr counselor and alternative health, and child advocate will be accepting applications for ASD families to be a part of our National Study to provide data for NDAR. National Data for Autistic Reasearch. For coming to us and allowing us to document progress as we utilize exposure to a very calm very grounding expreience and interaction with trained equine therapy horses, you will be a part of an elite study which will hopefully be extremely valuable data for research on the effectiveness of alternative therapies for ASD children. What makes us really unique is that we aslo will be working with the entire family as a unit not just the child. 

We are Horses Help Hearts Heal 

Dr Annabel Agee Phd, LPC, NCC, MHSP, 
 

Melissa Blaque, RCR, LRT, EALS, ES, DVLA, CASA
for more information please call: 865-206-7947 or 865-208-9555


ABA is good for teaching discrete skills to kids with autism. Actually, there are conflicting analyses of the ABA effectiveness literature....and generalization is still a major challenge. ANd, with ABA, a teacher can focus entirely on nonfunctional skills in isolation with ABA.

 

THere is now growing evidence of the usefulness of developmental interventions for kids on the spectrum, such as DIR. I think a combination of therapies, as DIR and ABA can help a child learn to read, for example, and also to relate and connect with other people.


Ayurveda for Autism Spectrum Disorder

Jan 4, 2011 by sunethriayurved...

Hi everybody,

I am Dr.Prasad M, MD (Ay.), working with autistic kids from 2002 onwards. I went through the article mentioned. Let me share with you an unbiased information on the scope of Ayurveda, the age-old Indian system of Vedic medicine, in the treatment of ASD. This is based 100% on my personal experiences. Kindly see the following passages. Comments and criticisms are welcomed whole-heatedly. 

Scope of Ayurveda in Autism Spectrum Disorder

Trials with Ayurvedic medicines and treatments for their efficacy in ASD are going on at various centres in India and abroad.   The main advantage of ayurvedic medicine is that it has got a magazine of safe therapeutic preparations of various forms which are developed by continuous trials and rectifications over thousands of years.  There are many preparations like kwatha (decoction), churna (powder), arishta (self-fermented beverage), gudika (pill), ghrtha (medicated ghee), thyla (medicated vegetable fats) etc.  In recent times, many of the herbs used in Ayurveda are proven to have excellent detoxifying effect as well as free radical- scavenging potential.  The therapeutic preparations like kwatha are combinations of many herbs.  These combinations are originally developed on the basis of ayurvedic principles.  Till recent times these formulations were not given due consideration by the western scientists.  But now the picture has changed. More and more ayurvedic preparations are under their evaluation.  In Ayurveda, the compounds as well as single herbs are used for different purposes of health care like pacifying vitiated functional units called doshas, eliminating excessive toxic accumulations, providing targeted nutrients to tissues, tuning the mind-body coordination, sharpening the efficacy of sense-organs, and so on.  These prescriptions are based on personalised evaluation of different aspects like body constitution, doshik status, power of digestion and assimilation, status of bowel evacuation, physical strength, mental constitution, and etc which is done by experienced physicians.  Mind is an important factor in the healing of any ailment.  It is assumed that mind is like ghee which is held inside a pot called body.  If the ghee is hot the pot also gets warmed and if the pot is hot definitely the ghee also will be hot.  You cannot expect warm ghee in a cool pot and wise versa.  Similarly, food is given the supreme role in the healing process as well as in the maintenance of health.  It is a basic concept in Ayurveda that there is no use for any medicine if one stick on to pathya (wholesome) food (as it brings about health spontaneously) and there is no use for any medicine if one stick on to apathya (nasty) food (as there is no scope for functioning of the medicine).   In the context of autism, these assumptions are extremely important and seen exceptionally beneficial. 

The care of autism, as per ayurvedic principles, is based on the protocol of a three-step intervention

  1. detoxifying the body by regulating the agni
  2. Cleansing the dhatus (body tissues) by medicines and therapies
  3. Enhancing the mental abilities like comprehension, memory etc. by promoting the Agni.

Again, though the stages are generalised the execution will be personalised. 

The first stage is based on medicines almost completely.  Medicinal preparations like purgatives, specific formulations for de-worming, for enhancing the functions of the liver and pancreas, for enhancing the digestive fire (Agni), and for regulating the intestinal motility are used in this stage.  Certain preparations meant for squeezing out heavy metals from the tissues are also used.  Turmeric, garlic, curry leaves, etc are having this advantage. 

Second phase is mainly comprised of massages.  Traditional methods like abhyanga (hot-oil massages), udwarthana (dry powder massages), pindasweda of various types, thalapothichilpizhichil, etc are used here.  These manoeuvres improve the muscle tone, reduce hyperactivity, create better motor coordination, and normalize most of the obsessive repetitive movements.  Child sleeps well.  The bowels become more regular at this stage.  He/she will be more receptive to commands or suggestions.  The demand for sensory stimulation slows down considerably and the symptoms like increased sensitivity to certain sounds (hyperacusis) slowly disappear.  There will be oral medications parallel to the therapies and a few of these medications will be carried over to the next phase as well.  

Third stage is very specific and sold not be started before the proper completion of the first two.  This is an important point as there is a general tendency to mark the condition as mental retardation and to prescribe brain tonics and memory boosters to all autistic kids indiscriminately.

The major therapies in this stage are shirodhara (pouring of liquids like oils on the head), shirovasthi (holding of medicated oils on the head inside specially designed leather-rims), shiropichu (wetting the scalp with oil bandages), dhoopanam (fumigation with specific medicines) etc along with specific medications like kallyanakam kashayam, indukantham kashayam, gorochanadi gudika,balakanakapathradi kashayam, sidharthakam gudika etc.  Certain specific herbs like sahadevi, sankhapushpi, vacha, vishnukranthietc are also used.  Follow up is done with ghee preparations like mahakallyanaka, mahapaisachika, brahmighrtha, saraswathaghrtha, etc. 

Conclusion

It is seen that the classical ayurvedic treatment done systematically give promising results in kids diagnosed with ASD.  But it should be emphasised that the level of improvements is different from child to child.  Another important point is that these interventions are made in a corrective manner.   The child gets relieved of a lot of physical problems and tantrums.  But this will not make him/her a normal child.  Intensive training and special education are needed to put him on track and to catch up the peers.  This requires the dedicated involvement of parents, special educators, and skilled professional like occupational therapists.



Please comment on effectiveness or other autism therapy topics.

  • Factsheet
  • Research
  • News
  • Comments.
  • Synonyms for effectiveness include: efficacy
    Share |